“The Donna Reed Show” was always praised for its fresh new take on the family-themed sitcom genre, constantly pushing the envelope and introducing unpopular opinions in its plots and characters, which greatly contributed to its success. This can be attributed to Donna Reed herself, her husband, and their team of writers.
However, in 1962, the whole team of writers for the show admitted that they had run out of new ideas for new episodes. They even considered ending the show at that time because they did not want to ruin the show’s reputation by airing too many poor-quality episodes and knew that even their die-hard fans would get tired of the show if it continued that way.
Re-Casting Guest Actors
Back in the time when "The Donna Reed Show" was televised, it was common practice for TV show casting agents to bring back actors to play other roles. That way they had a handful of actors at their disposal to play usually insignificant roles that the audience would probably not even notice. (Well, except for a few die-hard fans with a keen eye.)
"The Donna Reed Show" had its fair share of actors who appeared more than once, playing different roles throughout the show, these include Jimmy Hawkins, Richard Deacon, Gale Gordon, Miyoshi Umeki, Harvey Korman, Doodles Weaver, and Dick Wilson.
Esther Williams and Donna Reed
"The Donna Reed Show" has not only opened the doors for the success of Donna Reed’s career. Another actress whose career took off because of this show is none other than Donna Reed’s friend, Esther Williams. She and Donna Reed had been friends since the 1940s and they both started their Hollywood careers at around the same time.
They were also both signed to MGM and were considered two of the best rising stars of that time. Esther Williams was an American competitive swimmer before she became an actress. She was doing very well in her sport, as she had set multiple national and regional swimming records in her late teens as part of the Los Angeles Athletic Club swimming team.
An Attractive New Deal
Since "The Donna Reed Show" has become so popular and was still in high demand, its TV network, ABC, did not want to see the show end just yet. They have offered Donna Reed a new deal — a new contract for 3 more seasons with higher pay, and less number of episodes per season. Sweet deal!
They also added a lot of other minor incentives to convince Donna to continue with the show. As a producer, this was definitely a step in the right direction and Donna accepted the offer, meaning the show continued to air for 4 more years until its final episode on March 19, 1966.
Time for Family
Donna was looking for a way out, as she had very little time for her family and personal life, but what Donna really liked about the new contract was the fact that she needed to provide fewer episodes per year. Her first contract demanded most of her time and frankly, she was left exhausted.
So in 1963, Fabares left the show, as her character went off to college. But instead of ending the show then, they continued by introducing Paul Petersen’s younger sister, Patty Petersen, as an adopted daughter Trisha. "The Donna Reed Show" went on and remained as successful as it was before.